Quantifying survey expectations: What’s wrong with the probability approach?∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
We study a matched sample of individual stock market forecasts consisting of both qualitative and quantitative forecasts. This allows us to test for the quality of forecast quantification methods by comparing quantified qualitative forecasts with actual quantitative forecasts. Focusing mainly on the widely used quantification framework advocated by Carlson and Parkin (1975), the so-called “probability approach”, we find that quantified expectations derived from the probability approach display a surprisingly weak correlation with reported quantitative stock return forecasts. We trace the reason for this low correlation to the importance of asymmetric and time-varying thresholds, whereas individual heterogeneity across forecasters seems to play a minor role. Hence, our results suggest that qualitative survey data may not be a very useful device to obtain quantitative forecasts and we suggest ways to remedy this problem when designing qualitative surveys. JEL-Classification: C53, D84, G17
منابع مشابه
Evaluating the Criteria for Meeting Customer Expectations at the Total Quality Management Level, Using System Dynamics Approach
Success of total quality management is associated with the ability to learn, absorb, adapt and implement changes in organizational attitudes and to integrate them into the organization. The purpose of this study is to investigate and improve some undesirable behaviors against customer-oriented total quality, using system dynamics approach. After reviewing the theoretical literature and conducti...
متن کامل6xuyh\([shfwdwlrqv Survey Expectations *
This paper focusses on survey expectations and discusses their uses for testing and modeling of expectations. Alternative models of expectations formation are reviewed and the importance of allowing for heterogeneity of expectations is emphasized. A weak form of the rational expectations hypothesis which focusses on average expectations rather than individual expectations is advanced. Other mod...
متن کاملQuantifying the threshold frost hardiness for over-wintering survival of wheat in Iran, using simulation
The value of frost tolerance in wheat is increased with decreasing the temperature in late autumn and/or early winter (phase I, acclimation), then shows plateau state for a period with the coldest temperature (II), finally appears to decrease with warming the temperature (III, de-acclimation). This study was aimed to determine the threshold frost hardiness in wheat for avoiding ...
متن کاملA Appendix A : Derivation of Optimal
This paper focusses on survey expectations and discusses their uses for testing and modeling of expectations. Alternative models of expectations formation are reviewed and the importance of allowing for heterogeneity of expectations is emphasized. A weak form of the rational expectations hypothesis which focusses on average expectations rather than individual expectations is advanced. Other mod...
متن کامل